New Story
Mountville · PA · Private independent · K-12 combined
Similar nearby schools
Most similar nearby schools
Prospect Grove High School → River Rock Academy - Lancaster → Lancaster Country Day School → The Janus School → River Rock Academy Red Lion Campus → Soaring Heights School York → Sonlight River Brethren School → High Road School Of York →How New Story compares for families
What families should know about New Story.
- ▸ LocallyPA students outperform the US average on NAEP 8th-grade math (+4 points).
- ▸ vs Similar SchoolsThe closest comparables nearby: Prospect Grove High School, River Rock Academy - Lancaster, Lancaster Country Day School and 5 more. See the sidebar to compare side-by-side.
For Parents
Get alerts when New Story's numbers change
New admissions results, enrollment shifts, test scores — a few alerts a year, no spam. Your email also saves your list across devices.
Objective, government-grade data — no school pays us for placement.
🏛️ Your state's public flagship
Pennsylvania State University-Main Campus
The in-state tuition gap is the flagship's biggest draw — most in-state families pay far less than the out-of-state sticker. Average net price after aid runs about $32,875/yr. Admission odds depend on your student's GPA and test scores, not which high school they attend.
Source: IPEDS admissions, tuition & enrollment + College Scorecard net price. Flagship = the state's primary public research university.
Enrollment trend & projection
Private school enrollment comes from the NCES Private School Universe Survey (PSS), which is collected every other year — not annually like public-school data. The most recent published collection is 2021–22; NCES targeted spring 2026 for the 2023–24 release — we'll load it as soon as it's published.
If the recent trend holds…
At its recent rate of +12.1%/year, projecting from 2022's 109 students:
An extrapolation of the recent trajectory, not a forecast of the school's plans; ignores one-off shocks.
Most similar nearby high schools
The schools most like this one — same type, blended on distance and size — and where their enrollment is heading. These are the schools families here weigh against each other.
| School | Type | Miles | HS enrollment | Trend |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Prospect Grove High School Columbia |
Private | 2.3 | 26 | — |
| River Rock Academy - Lancaster Lancaster |
Private | 2.8 | 22 | — |
| Lancaster Country Day School Lancaster |
Private | 4.5 | 520 | +0.6% |
| The Janus School Mount Joy |
Private | 6.1 | 77 | +11.6% |
| River Rock Academy Red Lion Campus Lancaster |
Private | 14.7 | 51 | — |
| Soaring Heights School York Mount Wolf |
Private | 14.9 | 15 | — |
| Sonlight River Brethren School Mount Joy |
Private | 3.5 | 53 | +0.0% |
| High Road School Of York York |
Private | 16.5 | 44 | — |